This article reflects our general observations and opinions. It is not legal advice and not a definitive statement of California law, and every situation depends on its own facts.
An assignment clause says whether you can hand a contract to someone else, and a change-of-control clause says whether a sale of the company counts as doing so. In our experience these provisions sit quietly in the boilerplate until a business is sold, merged or restructured, and then they decide whether a key customer, supplier or landlord gets a say. Many a sale has been delayed by a consent nobody thought to ask for.
Our short answer: before you sign, find out whether an assignment needs consent, whether a sale of equity counts as an assignment, and what standard the other side must meet in giving or withholding consent. Before you sell, read every material contract with those three questions in mind.
Assignment is not one thing
As we use the terms, an assignment transfers your rights under a contract, while a delegation transfers your duties. A contract may restrict one, the other or both. Our general understanding is that, without a restriction, many contract rights can be assigned, though personal service obligations and rights where the identity of the party really matters are often treated differently. Because the default rules are uncertain at the edges, the clause in your contract is usually what controls, and it is worth reading carefully.
Some clauses prohibit assignment entirely. Others allow it with the other side’s consent. Others allow it freely to affiliates or to a successor of the whole business. The differences matter more than the headings suggest.
Change of control: the clause that catches equity sales
Here is the trap. If you sell assets, you assign contracts, and a consent clause applies in the obvious way. If you sell the stock or membership interests, the contracts stay with the same legal entity, and a plain assignment clause may not be triggered at all. Counterparties know this, so they add a change-of-control clause, or define assignment to include a transfer of a controlling interest by merger, operation of law or otherwise.
Ask what counts as control. It may be a percentage of voting equity, the power to direct management, or a transfer of all or substantially all assets. A drafting choice such as a ten percent threshold can capture a minority investment round that nobody would call a sale. We cover the deal-level picture in our article on buying or selling a business.
The consent standard is where the leverage lives
A clause that says “consent required” is only half a clause. The other half is the standard. Common versions say consent may not be unreasonably withheld, or may be withheld in the other side’s sole discretion, or is silent. Our reading is that silence tends to be argued in both directions, and that “sole discretion” language is worth a negotiation, because it can give the other party a veto it can price. A sensible middle position is consent not to be unreasonably withheld, conditioned or delayed, with a deemed-consent mechanism if the other side does not answer by a date.
Also look at what happens if you transfer without consent. Possible consequences include a right to terminate, a damages claim, an acceleration of payment, or simply that the transfer is ineffective as against the other party. A clause that makes a prohibited transfer void is different from one that makes it a breach.
Where this shows up in Los Angeles businesses
The most frequent pressure point we see is the commercial lease, where a landlord’s consent is often required for an assignment or a change in ownership, and where a sale of the business can stall until the landlord signs. We discuss the lease side in our article on assignment and subletting in commercial leases, including the landlord’s profit-sharing and recapture rights. Franchise agreements, licenses, vendor and distribution contracts, and loan documents are close behind. Personal guarantees raise their own question, since a guarantor often has to approve a successor, which we touch on in our article on personal guarantees.
A practical checklist
- List every contract that matters to the value of the business, not only the largest by revenue.
- For each one, record whether assignment, delegation and a change of control need consent.
- Check the definition of control, any carve-outs for affiliates, and the consent standard.
- Note the consequences of a transfer without consent, and any notice period before a transfer.
- Decide the order of requests. Asking the most difficult counterparty last can leave you with no time.
Candid limits
We would not promise that a consent can always be obtained, or obtained cheaply. A counterparty with real leverage may ask for money, an amendment or a guarantee in return for signing, and a buyer may price that in. In some cases the practical answer is to restructure the deal, for example selling equity rather than assets or the reverse, and the tax and liability consequences of that choice belong in a conversation with your accountant as well as your lawyer.
Talking to us
We help business owners review the contracts in a sale or restructuring and negotiate consents. Our contract and transactional work is billed hourly or for a flat fee agreed in advance, not on contingency. Nothing here guarantees any result, and every contract turns on its own wording. Call us at (310) 556-9692.
Related reading: our contracts guide, buying or selling a business, what makes a contract enforceable, and indemnification clauses.
This article is general information only. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship, and it should not be relied on in place of advice about your own contract.