This article reflects our general observations and opinions. It is not legal advice and not a definitive statement of California law, and every situation depends on its own facts.
Older Los Angeles buildings have parapets, cornices, balconies, signs and facade cladding that were installed decades ago, and some of them come loose. When a piece of a building or something dropped from a height injures a person on the sidewalk below, the first question is who was responsible for that part of the structure. In our experience the answer is rarely obvious from the street, and the people who can answer it, such as the owner, a property manager, a contractor, or a tenant who installed a sign, often point at one another.
Our short answer: a falling-object injury claim usually turns on who controlled the thing that fell, what they knew or should have known about its condition, and what inspections and maintenance records exist. Preserving the object, photographing the scene and identifying the building quickly all matter. We cannot predict how any claim will end, and no outcome is guaranteed.
Why this is a distinct kind of claim
A falling-object case is related to the premises liability analysis we discussed in our article on premises liability at a Los Angeles apartment building, but it has its own features. The injured person is often a pedestrian with no relationship to the property. The hazard is above head height and invisible to a passer-by. And the evidence is physical: the fragment, the fixture, the bracket, the anchor points. Those things can be repaired, replaced or thrown away within days.
Who may be responsible
- The building owner, who generally has responsibility for the structure and the facade, and who may have inspection duties for certain buildings.
- A property manager, who may have undertaken maintenance responsibilities by contract.
- A tenant, for a sign, awning or fixture it installed and maintained.
- A contractor, where work was in progress or recently completed, such as scaffolding, window work, roofing or signage.
- A public entity, where the falling object was part of a public structure or street fixture. That brings in a short claim deadline, which we describe in our article on the government claim deadline.
Los Angeles buildings and the usual suspects
The hazards we hear about most often are not exotic. Decorative stucco and tile that has lost its bond with the wall behind it, balcony railings and planter boxes on older apartment buildings, rooftop equipment and signs bolted to parapets, window glass in older commercial storefronts, and scaffolding or sidewalk sheds during renovation. Seismic retrofit work and water intrusion over many years can leave anchors corroded or masonry loosened in ways nobody sees from the ground. Wind events in the Los Angeles area can turn a loosely secured fixture into a projectile. None of this means a given building is dangerous, but it explains why the question of inspection and maintenance history carries so much weight when something does fall.
It also explains why the identity of the building matters so early. A pedestrian who is hit and leaves without noting the address may find it hard to reconstruct where it happened. A quick photograph of the street sign, storefront or nearby landmarks can save a great deal of effort later.
What the owner knew, and what an inspection would have shown
As we understand it, claims against a property owner for a dangerous condition generally depend on whether the owner knew or reasonably should have known of the condition in time to fix or warn about it. That question is where the maintenance history matters. Records of past inspections, repair requests, prior pieces falling, City notices, permit applications for facade repair, and insurance inspection reports can all bear on the question. For some taller buildings, local rules require periodic facade inspections, and a missed or ignored report can be significant. Whether a particular building was subject to such a requirement is a factual question we would want to check rather than assume.
Evidence of earlier warning signs, such as visible cracking, loose cladding, water staining or earlier repairs, is also important. These are the facts a building owner usually has to explain.
Steps worth taking quickly
- Get medical care and keep records. A falling object can cause injuries that are not apparent right away.
- Photograph the object, the area above it and the surroundings, including street signs and addresses that identify the building.
- Do not discard clothing or belongings that were hit or damaged.
- Identify witnesses and nearby cameras, and note whether the business next door has video. Footage is often overwritten within days.
- Be careful with early insurer contact, for the reasons we describe in our article on recorded statements.
Candid limits
These cases can be difficult. If the object is gone and nobody knows where it came from, proof of ownership and control may be hard. A building owner may say that it had no warning, or that a contractor or tenant was responsible, and sorting that out takes time. California applies comparative fault, so a defendant may argue that a person ignored a barrier or warning, as we explain in our article on comparative fault. And the deadline to bring a claim depends on who is responsible, as we discuss in the piece on the statute of limitations on an injury claim.
Talking to us
If you were injured by something that fell from a building in Los Angeles, you are welcome to call us at (310) 556-9692. For personal injury matters our fees are taken from any recovery, costs are separate, and the arrangement is set out in a written fee agreement. No outcome is guaranteed, and past results do not predict future results.
Related reading: our personal injury guide, injured on a Los Angeles sidewalk, and premises liability at an apartment building.
This article is general information only. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship, and it should not be relied on in place of advice about your own claim.