This article reflects our general observations and opinions. It is not legal advice and not a definitive statement of California law, and every situation depends on its own facts.
When a customer, or a lawyer on a customer’s behalf, says a storefront is not accessible, the first question a Los Angeles tenant asks is usually “whose problem is this?” In our experience the honest answer is that both landlord and tenant can be named, and the lease decides who ultimately pays. A form lease that says nothing useful on the point can leave a tenant paying for a sidewalk ramp, a parking space or a restroom door it never built.
Our short answer: before you sign, find out the accessibility condition of the space, who is responsible for each part of it, and whether the lease gives you the right to an inspection. After you sign, treat an accessibility demand letter as time sensitive and read it with a lawyer.
Why this is so common in Los Angeles
Federal and California accessibility law applies to places open to the public, and California has its own civil rights remedies on top of the federal rules. The practical result, as we see it, is a steady stream of demand letters and lawsuits aimed at small businesses over physical barriers: entrance thresholds, door hardware, counter heights, restroom layouts, parking striping and signs. Older LA strip centers and converted buildings are particularly exposed, because they were built or altered before many of today’s standards existed.
Many of these claims are not large in a single instance. The difficulty is that the business receiving one has to respond quickly, may have to pay to fix something it does not control, and may face the claim even if it moved in last month.
Who is responsible, as between landlord and tenant
As we understand it, a landlord and a tenant can each be responsible to the public, and the lease is what allocates the cost between them. The usual pattern is that the landlord keeps responsibility for common areas, such as parking, paths of travel and shared restrooms, while the tenant takes responsibility for the interior of its own space and for any alteration it makes. The weak points are the places in between: the entrance door, the threshold, the sidewalk apron, a ramp shared with a neighbor, and a restroom that serves several tenants.
What to look at in the lease
- The compliance clause. Does the lease require the tenant to comply with all laws, including accessibility laws, in its own space? Does it say anything about the landlord’s obligation for common areas?
- Representations about condition. Some leases include a statement from the landlord about the space’s accessibility status. Many say nothing, or say the tenant accepts the premises as is.
- Alterations. If your build-out triggers accessibility upgrades in the surrounding path of travel, who pays? This often surprises tenants in the middle of construction.
- Indemnity and defense. Who defends and pays when a claim is made, and does the clause apply regardless of who was at fault? See our discussion of indemnification clauses.
- Cost pass-throughs. Can the landlord recover the cost of common-area upgrades through operating expenses, as discussed in our article on CAM charges?
The inspection question
California has a program of certified access specialists, usually called CASp inspectors, and the inspection report can be used to establish the condition of a property. Our understanding is that certain procedural protections for a defendant may be available to a business that has had a qualifying inspection or that occupies a qualifying inspected site, and that leases are expected to say whether a CASp inspection has been done and who may arrange one. The details are technical, and we would not rely on a general summary. What we can say is that a tenant who is deciding whether to sign should ask early whether the space has been inspected, and should consider whether to commission its own inspection before signing, with the lease saying who bears the cost of what it finds.
If a demand letter arrives
Do not ignore it, and do not simply pay it without understanding what you are paying for. Gather the lease, any inspection report, and a list of what the letter says is wrong. Tell your landlord promptly, because the lease may require notice and may give you a right to indemnity. Keep records of any repair, with dates and photographs. Deadlines in these cases can be short.
Candid limits
We cannot tell you in the abstract who will end up paying. A tenant with a strong negotiating position may get the landlord to take responsibility for exterior and common-area barriers. A tenant in a competitive market may not. Landlords commonly resist taking on open-ended exposure, and some will agree only to fix conditions identified by an inspection. We also would not suggest treating accessibility as a purely legal question: fixing an obvious problem is usually cheaper than defending it.
Talking to us
We review and negotiate commercial leases for Los Angeles tenants and owners. Our lease work is billed hourly or for a flat fee agreed in advance, not on contingency. Nothing here guarantees any result, and every lease turns on its own wording. Call us at (310) 556-9692.
Related reading: our commercial lease negotiation guide, who pays for HVAC and roof repairs, tenant improvement allowances, and assignment and subletting.
This article is general information only. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship, and it should not be relied on in place of advice about your own lease.